Can the creation of guardianship by a parent be challenged?

, , ,

It is wise for parents to name legal and physical guardians of their minor children to serve in the event of their deaths. But the creation of a guardianship by a parent is not always controlling.

Pennsylvania law provides that all custody cases must be decided in the best interests of the child. Anything which can have an effect on the child’s physical, intellectual, moral and spiritual well-being is considered by the court in choosing a custodian or guardian.

A sole surviving parent may name a guardian to take custody of a child upon the parent’s death. But other relatives or adults significantly attached to the child later can challenge the guardianship and seek custody of the child. The court initially will presume that the parent’s choice of guardian is the best choice. However, the court will listen to testimony from challengers and will consider whether others interested in the child’s care might be better custodians. Anyone who challenges a deceased parent’s choice of guardian has a heavy burden to prove that the court should reject the parent’s choice.

Where parents are separated or divorced, and the parent with whom the child resides dies, the surviving parent has custodial rights superior to those of any guardian named by the deceased parent. A natural parent’s custody rights can’t be terminated by the death of the other parent. If the surviving natural parent is incompetent, unfit, missing or unwilling to care for the child, the court can award custody to a guardian named by the deceased parent. Additionally, if a guardian named by the deceased parent has provided essential parenting for the child, he or she may have standing to challenge a competent, interested natural parent’s rights. But the strong rights of the natural parent are very difficult to defeat.

Whether married, separated or divorced, parents should strive to cooperate to identify a mutually acceptable guardian to take custody of their minor children in the event of their deaths. Where separated or divorced parents can’t agree, each must realize that the courts will favor the surviving parent but will consider the claims of involved third parties, especially those identified as preferred custodians by the deceased parent.